Rise and Fall (of Zardari)

(This piece appeared in The News the day of the NRO debacle by Zardari)
Monday, November 02, 2009
Nawab Mumtaz Ali Bhutto

Mumtaz Bhutto

Mumtaz Bhutto

Readers will recall my repeated warnings that a man with Zardari’s reputation, who has no educational or political background and lacks all the other prerequisites of leadership, will be an absolute disaster in a minor office, let alone the top position in the country. This has proved to be true in a short period leading to a nationwide upheaval. His claim to fame rests entirely on being the husband of Shaheed Benazir Bhutto and spending eight years in jail. Let us look at these laurels a bit closely.

Shaheed Benazir, in her book Daughter of the East, says that she married him because of relentless pressure from her mother and aunts, and because of his own persistence. It is surprising, however, that she was unable to control him during her two terms in office, during which time he came to be called Mr Ten Percent. For the veracity of this epithet, let us not depend on the corruption cases against him, even though two—the Surrey Palace and money-laundering cases in Jersey and Switzerland—stand proved, but listen to the laments of the people at large and even jiyalas.

Accepting the principle that there is no smoke without fire and the fact that before marriage, the Zardari family had nothing to show but a cinema house in Karachi, many questions arise about his lifestyle not only in the country but more so abroad. For instance, he recently took a planeload of people for Umra and claimed to have paid for their travel out of his own pocket–approximately twenty five million rupees–and also gave five million rupees to his old school, THE Cadet College, Petaro. During these days of worldwide economic collapse, when even international banks have been wiped out, for someone to throw money around in this manner indicates a huge reservoir of wealth. Added to the corruption cases are the four murder charges against him, including that of Shaheed Mir Murtaza Bhutto, who was gunned down by the police in broad daylight, at a time when Murtaza’s sister was prime minister of Pakistan. It is very significant that now all the involved policemen not only walk free but have been handsomely rewarded. All the above is a matter of record and cannot be denied or concealed.

It is claimed that the two years Zardari spent in jails and six in a luxury hospital in Islamabad are a sacrifice for the nation, which establish his being in the highest offices in the country. No one cares that such a concession is extremely dangerous since it opens the portals of power to all kinds of characters. Of course, the beneficiaries of Zardari’s meteoric assent from purgatory to the Presidency explain away that he was not convicted in the long period of ten years and is therefore innocent. Not quite so. It cannot be concealed that he was not acquitted either, and he and his cohorts have been reprieved only by the unconstitutional and immoral NRO. Besides, in public life it is what people believe and the disgrace faced that matter, not conviction. He was elected president on an indirect vote of assembly members. He got a mandate to avenge the murder of Shaheed Benazir and provide “roti, kapra, makan” to the people (they have done neither). If even at the emotionally charged time of the polls this question had been put to the people the answer would definitely have been in the negative as people hold the president guilty as charged and also responsible for the murder of his wife, whose killers he professes to know. The belief is strengthened by the fact that no complaint has been filed in almost two years, which normally is a knee-jerk reaction to even a petty crime, let alone the murder of an international leader and mother of his children, and in whose name he continues to thrive. As for the long duration of the trials, eight years is no big deal. We all know and, speaking from personal experience, cases in our courts go on forever. However, the delay was compounded by Zardari himself, who claimed mental illness, heart trouble and back pain (all of which have suddenly disappeared) to obstruct progress and conviction.

As for the distress of imprisonment, here too there is no cause for complaint, he being most of the time ensconced in a luxury hospital where all the comforts of a five-star hotel were available, together with unrestricted visitors and frequent releases on parole, with first-class travel at government expense.

Starting with Zardari’s negative stand on the judges’ issue, despite repeated promises to the contrary, dodging the repeal of the 17th Amendment and Article 58(2)(b), failure to provide any relief to the masses, right up to plunging the country into civil war, it has become impossible to keep him afloat. The honourable thing for him to do is to quit and take with him the team of his partners who surround him. What is desperately required in the present mess is a leader in the true sense of the word, who commands trust and respect.

The chaos that is rampant today is the consequence of not only the president being unfit for the job but also the concept of “reconciliation.” This has given us a political setup, devoid of ideology and principals in which it is proudly proclaimed there is no last word, allowing lots of space for playing tricks. “Reconciliation” is merely an invitation to come and sit at the banquet of government and indulge to the limit. The main purpose is to rope in all dissent so that no one is left out to complain. As a consequence we have the proponents of Nizam-e-Mustafa/Shariat, leftists, rightists, nationalists, adventures with no commitment to the people, who believe only in being with the government of the day to enjoy the perks of power. Such a conglomerate of clashing interests is a non-starter ab initio. Apart from the huge costs to the exchequer of providing ministerial portfolios to all and sundry and accommodating everyone to his satisfaction, it is impossible to have a lasting state of harmony among these basically conflicting interests, as we see today.

There is nothing for the people in “reconciliation” as the experience of almost two years has proved. Never before have the people of Pakistan been so deprived and destitute and the government of the day so helpless and useless. There is no surprise that reconciliation has blown up and the country is at the crossroads of uncertainty and panic as never before. This scenario was easy to predicted at the start when, of all people, Zardari become the master of the destiny of one hundred and seventy million Pakistanis.

The writer is chairman of the Sindh National Front.

DAWN Editorial: A sinking presidency
A Year of Zardari by Murtaza Bhutto


3 Responses to “Rise and Fall (of Zardari)”

  1. 1 Observer November 4, 2009 at 1:38 pm

    “Readers will recall my repeated warnings that a man with Zardari’s reputation, who has no educational or political background and lacks all the other prerequisites of leadership, will be an absolute disaster in a minor office, let alone the top position in the country.”

    This is common knowledge. Everyone knows that – also the illiterate persons.

    I will go a little further and say that the whole lot of piplyas are rotten to the core including the likes of Aitezaz Ahsen – at least as much as Zardari – if not more. They have been licking his boots ever since he got his wife killed and continue to recognise him as their legitimate leader. In other words we should not target Zardari alone, but also his comrades from PPP and business crooks like Malik Riaz.

  2. 3 Mehwish November 6, 2009 at 4:22 am

    The criticism of Mr Bhutto about President Zardari’s expenditures and resources seems totally biased and hypocritical as Nawab sahib, a self-proclaimed chieftain of the Bhutto tribe, has never made his assets public nor is there any public information about his tax returns. This is not a secret though that Mr Mumtaz Bhutto owns huge land holdings and urban assets and enjoys a lavish lifestyle while his own haris are deprived of basic necessity like clean water.

    As regards his venom against the democratic process and President Zardari’s regime, one can clearly feel the love for power which makes Mr Mumtaz Bhutto dream for an unconstitutional change thus creating an opportunity of becoming a ‘caretaker’ — once again. There is a democratic set-up in place and parliament has a legitimate right to complete its constitutional term. Like it or not Nawab sahib, you have to wait and let the political process take its course.

    Another alternate Mr Bhutto can resort to is to go back to his parent political party, the PPP, become a part of the democratic process and raise his voice inside the party and in parliament. If Mr Bhutto has decided to stay away from the democratic process then the best course for him is to sit back and wait for the present regime to come back to the people in the next election. If President Zardari is such a failure, people will reject him in the next election.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: